Wow, it’s been a while. I guess I kinda fell off the face of the earth there. What’ve I been up to? Lots of writing, lots of querying, lots of working.
I joined Critters, an online critique group for SF/F/H writers last month and my story made its way to the top of the queue this last week. I received back several useful, constructive, and excellent critiques. A couple of people had some very helpful things to say about the pacing of the story and I am grateful for their input.
I do have one little beef with Critters as to what counts as a critique. I received several critiques that were mere summaries of the short story I had submitted followed by the words, “I liked it.” Great, I’m glad you liked it. Correct me if I’m wrong, but a summary is not a critique, nor are the vague words “I liked it.” What did you like about it? Everything? Really, please be a little more specific.
I think there should be a way to contest the summaries; they should not be counted towards critique points. I’m sure I’ve just pissed off the people who sent me summaries, but what are the chances that they’re reading my blog? Well, I’ve got their names, and the next time their stories are at the top of the queue, maybe I’ll disappoint them by sending them a mere summary and the words “I liked it” if I like their story or the words “I didn’t like it” if I don’t. Nah, that’s mean. If I happen to read their pieces, I will give them the critique that piece is worth. Maybe it’ll show them how critiques ought to be written. Please, ditch the summary and focus on specifics, thanks.